Your domain registration is pending. Check back in an hour


This week we have officially reopened outside seating as well as our full-time hours, 7:30 AM to 6:30 PM!

Want to try our delicious key lime pie but don't want a full one? We are now serving minis! These bite-sized pies are just enough to satisfy your sweet tooth and get a taste before you buy! Get one while they last!

We will be open this upcoming week! Hours Tues-Thusday 7:30-3:00 Friday 7:30 to Grill off 6:30. Hope to see you!!

Apart from our personal veggie orders we will also be making homemade Keylime Pies! Order a day in advance, we will have it ready for you by the next day! Indulge this quarantine!

Call now

Due to COVID-19 we have come up with some new business ventures here at the shack! We will now be doing personalized veggie orders. Call one day in advance and we will order your veggies for you! Let us save you a trip to Acme!

Call now

Great first weekend! Thank you for all the business. We now have Venmo to pay! When using this if you choose to tip please write the amount you tip in the description on Venmo. Our @ is @theoldshack and the name attached to the account is Stephanie Muller! Cash transactions are still available!

Our first weekend open will be May 16th 2020! We will not have a full menu for takeout, updates to come!

Although we lost our spring to COVID-19, that doesn't mean we need to lose our summer! If lockdown continues into June (or further) we will be doing take out! Call in a delicious stack of pancakes for breakfast or a savory cheesesteak for lunch, being quarantined doesn't mean we can't enjoy mouth...

Read More


2 years ago
I had a fantastic lunch here! I ordered a sub sandwich and it tasted terrific. They have a huge menu selection and relatively low prices. The staff was also very friendly and the service was quick. With a big menu selection, great food, nice service, and low prices, I honestly couldn’t ask for more. I’d recommend this to anyone.
4 years ago
Great old style sandwich shop and the food is great. Super friendly and dogs are welcome. They deliver to the beach too.
- John M
3 years ago
Great Philadelphia hoagies and other great fare. A hidden gem at the Jersey shore, deserves to be packed every day.
- Ryan R


Serving up delicious American style food since 1999! 

Contact Us


Call now
  • (609) 263-7773


Get directions
705 Commonwealth Avenue
Strathmere, NJ 08248

Business Hours

Mon:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Tue:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Wed:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Thu:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Fri:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Sat:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Sun:7:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Contact Us
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.